Return to Homepage Danae
29th June 1998 The Rose Garden
Penelope

Hybrid Musk Roses

by Lloyd Chapman


`
All roses are subject to fashion. This article chronicles a family of roses developed in the twentieth century that enjoyed huge popularity, but then fell from favour, for no other reason than the arrival of a new rose fashion, the floribunda.

Many of us grow Buff Beauty, some recognise Ballerina and Penelope, but few appreciate the breadth and beauty of this hardy healthy family of shrub roses. Fear not, by the time you've finished, you'll better understand the enduring beauty of a family of roses that deserves your attention.

The Heritage Rose police will doubtless take me to task for applauding roses from this century. Nonsense ! Age does not confer greatness, nor are all modern roses to be sneered at. Equally we should resist the temptation to eulogise David Austin's expanding family at the expense of all other interesting roses.

The name is confusing. We know the Musk rose which descends from R. Moschata as a huge summer-flowering family coming from the Middle-East several centuries ago. Vigorous climbers, mostly with wicked thorns, the Musk Hybrids we know today include The Garland, Paul's Himalayan Musk, Moschata floribunda and the Persian Musk Rose, Moschata nastarana.
Hybrid Musks should not be confused with these monsters.

The family is the product of an Englishman Rev. Pemberton who devoted twelve years of his retirement to the breeding and growing of roses. His early interest, encouraged by his sister, was growing and showing roses. He was one of the early members of the National Rose Society. Jack Harkness writes 'He served the rose and the National Rose Society with unusual flair and vigour'. His book Roses, their History, Development and Cultivation' published early this century, before his retirement became a standard work. When he died in 1926, his gardeners, the Bentalls carried on his work, releasing further examples of the family. Ballerina & Buff Beauty were their most important introductions. They undoubtedly owed much to Pemberton's work. In 1932, Ann Bentall released The Fairy, which remains popular today. Mention should also be made of Kordes in Germany, Thomas in California and latterly Beales in England for the production of further derivatives.

Many early Hybrid Musks have Trier as a parent, an interesting shrub produced by Lambert in 1901. Named after the German town, it was a seedling of the Multiflora/Noisette hybrid Aglaia, and was the first recurrent shrub rose. Trier is a tallish shrub bearing clusters of small dainty creamy-apricot blooms, with good fragrance and repeat-flowering. Pemberton must have seen something desirable in Trier, using it for his early releases. It occupies a special place in our garden, both for its style and class, as well as its historical significance. Its style exemplifies much of the Hybrid Musk family.

Some say that its fragrance is of musk, which would have been inherited from the links to Moschata via Noisette and Multiflora parentage. Certainly many Hybrid Musks have relatively thornless wood that is reminiscent of these families. Equally certainly, the links to moschata are tenuous.

Today there are over 30 Hybrid Musks commercially available in New Zealand, with new members occasionally extending the family. We grow 28 and like obsessive collectors, we seek to complete the collection. Where to put them becomes a problem in a garden approaching its limits.

Hybrid Musks produce blooms in very large clusters, are fragrant and recurrent. It is said that dead-heading will stimulate remontancy, but left alone you can still expect them to flower from spring to autumn. Many produce hips, generally quite dainty. Some will climb if given the chance, most will grow to 1.5 metres if you let them.

They are not out of place anywhere in the garden. As shrub-climbers they provide cheerful background colour, especially with their healthy foliage. As shrubs they look good in a mixed border; as specimens they stand alone well, while they grow well as free-standing hedges. They fill the colour spectrum from soft pastels to startling vibrant scarlets. These are the Hybrid Musks we grow (in order of introduction) * rating is my subjective opinion.

Danae **   1913 Pemberton Trier x Gloire de Chedane-Guinosseau
Danae and Moonlight were Pemberton's first releases. Butter-yellow blooms age to cream. Very free-flowering. Nice healthy foliage. Deserves to be better-known.
Danae
Moonlight ***   1913 Pemberton Trier x Sulphurea
Classic white rose with wonderful foliage. Creamy- white fragrant blooms make a great display. The contrast of the pure white blooms in big clusters contrasts well with the healthy dark green foliage and the dark brown-red wood. I read somewhere of Moonlight as the 'thinking person's Iceberg. Definitely a superior rose. Certainly this rose has more character and style.
Moonlight
Daybreak *   1918 Pemberton Trier x Liberty
Lemon-yellow blooms fading to primrose. Fragrant. Copper juvenile foliage. Tidy refined shrub. Same parents as the admired Clytemnestra.
Daybreak
Pax   1918 Pemberton Trier x Sunburst
Its introduction was timed to celebrate the end of the first world war. Although Pax was white, Sunburst, which Pemberton also used in the breeding of Francesca was a yellow-orange hybrid tea developed by Pernet-Ducher. Continuous-flowering, best in the autumn.
Pax
Penelope ***   1924 Pemberton Ophelia x ?
Much admired classic. Large semi-double creamy-pink blooms are nicely fragrant. Prominent stamens, excellent healthy foliage. The influence of the mighty Ophelia is seen once more. Everyone should grow this rose. We have it mass planted.
Penelope
Bloomfield Dainty **   1924 Thomas, Danae x Mme Edouard Herriot
A treasure. Long pointed orange buds open to soft lemon single blooms. Not the hardiest, but definitely one of the most interesting. Shorter-growing, deserves attention. George C Thomas was a prolific Californian hybridist, being responsible from 1920 to 1931 for over 20 roses with the Bloomfield name, of which half were Hybrid Musks. Like Pemberton, he used Danae extensively as a parent, crossing it mostly with older European roses. He is best remembered for Abundance, which will always be confused with Cecile Brunner.
Bloomfield Dainty
Heideroslein   1932 Lambert Chamisso x Amalie de Greiff
'the heather rose' Pretty single pink blooms on a taller upright shrub. Not well known but worth growing.
Heideroslein
Cornelia **   1925 Pemberton
Small fully double apricot-pink blooms, flushed deeper pink borne in large clusters. Good dark foliage. A very good taller shrub that will climb if encouraged. Excellent autumn display. Very healthy.
Cornelia
Erfurt   1931 Kordes Eva x Reveil Dijonnais
Larger semi-double rose-carmine blooms. Fragrant and long-flowering.
Erfurt
Ballerina **   1937 Bentall Robin Hood x ?
Outstanding and versatile shrub/climber. Huge sprays of clear pink single blooms Glossy foliage, which is not typical of many Pemberton musks. Very tough, disease-free and worthwhile. Will easily achieve 2 metres, probably best against a fence where it can sprawl.
Ballerina
Buff Beauty *** 1939 Pemberton, but released by Bentall William Allen Richardson x seedlin
Well-liked shrub/climber. Outstanding foliage, trusses of strongly-scented buff-apricot blooms. Can be persuaded to climb, but will grow happily as a shrub.
Buff Beauty
Sally Holmes ***   1976 Holmes Ivory Fashion x Ballerina
One of the healthiest and most spectacular roses we grow. Huge heads of big single white blooms, arching growth that will climb if you don't prune it hard. Buds have an alluring ivory tinge, then open to impressive big flat single creamy-white blooms. Good glossy foliage. Not many people realise its Hybrid Musk parentage.
Sally Holmes
Clytemnestra **  1915 Pemberton Trier x Liberty
Rare and unusual, Sprawling bush with lemony-beige blooms. Fragrant and recurrent. We like this one a lot, especially for its lower-growing habit and cheerful demeanour. Pemberton must have liked the result as he produced another cross three years later to get Daybreak.
Prosperity **   1919 Pemberton Marie-Jeanne x Perle des Jardins
Large double creamy-white fragrant blooms in bunches. Sweetly scented. Nice contrast with dark healthy foliage. Recommended
Vanity   1920 Pemberton Chateau de Clos Vougeot x Seedling
Vigorous shrub. Single bright rose-pink blooms. A bit garish.
Nur Mahal   1923 Pemberton Chateau de Clos Vougeot x seedling
Showy vibrant crimson blooms in clusters. Good dark foliage. Would look good mass planted. Nur Mahal was the wife of the Emperor Jahangir of India and is credited with the discovery of Attar of roses, ironic since this is one of the least fragrant.
Bishop Darlington *   1926 Thomas Aviateur Bleriot x Moonlight
Elegant pointed buds more reminiscent of a tea rose, large semi-double blooms are creamy-white with a yellow base, strongly fragrant. Not a typical Hybrid Musk.
Robin Hood   1927 Pemberton Seedling x Mrs Edith Cavell
Introduced the year after Pemberton's death by his sister. Large clusters of bright scarlet-red blooms. More prickly than most musks. It has enormous health and toughness that have been utilised in breed in of many roses. Robin Hood became a valuable parent in the hands of Kordes. He produced 'a race of very hardy continuous-flowering shrub roses' including Hamburg, Bonn and Elmshorn. Kordes and his roses deserve an article to themselves.
Felicia **   1928 Pemberton Trier x Ophelia
Outstanding large shrub. Rich pink blooms with salmon shadings and great fragrance. Tough and reliable. It grows in our garden as a bush, hard pruned, and also as a shrub against a fence, where it gets less attention. It's not surprising that this is a great rose - anything crossed with Ophelia is guaranteed stardom. She is one of the old hybrid teas most often encountered in the breeding of modern roses.
Francesca ** 1928 Pemberton Danae x Sunburst
Large sprays of semi-double apricot-yellow blooms, contrast well with darker green glossy foliage.
Pink Prosperity   1931 Bentall
Tall shrub. Small clear pink blooms in clusters.
Ausonius *   1932 Lambert (Chamisso x Leonie Lamesch) x (Geheimrat Dr Mittweg x Tip Top)
Taller grower Clusters of pinkish-yellow semi-single blooms with white eye. Profuse and with good fragrance. Not well known.
Autumn Delight *   1933 Bentall
Soft semi-double buff-yellow fragrant blooms with prominent stamens on an upright thornless shrub. Dark green foliage.
Wilhelm   1934 Kordes Robin Hood x J C Thornton
'Skyrocket' Blackish buds, single crimson blooms in clusters. At its best in the autumn. Bright orange hips.
Lavender Lassie   1960 Kordes Hamburg x Mme Norbert Levavasseur
Lilac-pink blooms, medium-sized and rosette-shaped in loose trusses on a versatile tall spreading shrub. Moderately fragrant. Vigorous and healthy
Marjorie Fair *   1960 Harkness Ballerina x Baby Faraux
A recent Harkness introduction. Spectacularly huge trusses of strong single red blooms, with a white eye. This is a tough grow-anywhere rose, inheriting all the tough qualities of Ballerina. The other parent is one of the darkest purple polyanthas. The combination is startling, perhaps not to everyone's taste.
Menja 197? Petersen
Taller shrub, masses of small cupped pink blooms. Tiny orange-red hips.
Sadlers Wells **   1983 Beales Penelope x Rose Gaujard
Big deep pink ruffled single blooms, paler at the centre. Beales describes as 'the background colour is silvery-pink, each petal laced with cherry-red' Nice dark foliage, blooms are weather-resistant. Destined to become well known. Looks very good planted in a group of 3 or more.
Copyright Lloyd Chapman Winter 1998
 

More pictures of Old Roses from Trinity Farm in the Garden Gallery.


More articles by Lloyd Chapman

Purple Ramblers    January 2002
The Endless Charm of Rugosas    June 2000
Winter care in the Rose garden    Winter 2000
The Three Graces in the Rose Garden    Sept 1999
Alba Roses   January 1999
Single Roses   December 1997
Moss Roses   September 1997
Damask Roses   July 1997
The Glory of Wichuraiana Ramblers   June 1997




Return to Gardens ONLINE    Garden Gallery    Mail Order Nurseries    Letters    Garden Notes
The Rose Garden Index    Gardens to Visit


This page has been accessed times since 29th June 1998


Copyright © 1997 Netlist Ltd
All enquiries to wendy@netlist.co.nz